Toilet Rebuild vs. Replacement Guide

Deciding to Repair or Replace

The first step is to determine what the problem is. Some issues, like a broken flapper valve or a worn-out fill valve, are minor and easily fixed with a toilet repair. A rebuild usually involves replacing internal components to restore functionality without replacing the entire fixture. However, if your toilet has structural damage, cracks, or frequent clogs, it might be time to consider a complete toilet replacement. Here are some common signs you can likely fix with a rebuild:

• Constantly running water caused by a faulty flapper or fill valve.
• Difficulty flushing due to worn-out handle or chain mechanisms.
• Water pooling at the base could indicate a leaky gasket.

Understanding the Costs

Budget plays a central role in deciding between a rebuild and a replacement. A toilet repair focusing on internal parts like seals and valves is typically less expensive than a full toilet installation. Rebuilds are a cost-effective choice for homeowners who want to extend the life of their existing fixture without the added expense of purchasing a new unit. However, if your toilet has reached the end of its lifespan, investing in a replacement could save you money in the long run. Modern toilets are more water-efficient, so they can help lower your monthly utility bills. A new installation should also come with a manufacturer’s warranty, which can protect against future issues.

Environmental Impact

Older toilets manufactured before the 1990s can use up to five gallons of water per flush. Newer models are designed to use as little as 1.28 gallons per flush, which meets EPA’s WaterSense criteria. If environmental sustainability is important to you, replacing an outdated toilet with a high-efficiency model is the greener choice. While a rebuild might fix your toilet trouble, it won’t improve water usage if your toilet is outdated and inefficient.

How Long Should Toilets Last?

On average, a well-maintained toilet can function efficiently for 25 years or more. Regular wear and tear, hard water deposits, and frequent use can shorten its lifespan. While many internal parts are replaceable, structural issues or recurring problems might mean that it’s time for a toilet replacement. If you’re not sure about the age of your toilet or its overall condition, consider scheduling a professional inspection. Local plumbers can identify hidden issues that might influence your decision.

What’s Involved in a Rebuild?

A toilet rebuild focuses on replacing worn-out components inside the tank and base. Common parts involved in a rebuild include:

• Flapper Valve: Controls the release of water during a flush.
• Fill Valve: Regulates the water refilling the tank.
• Flush Handle and Chain: Activates the flushing mechanism.
• Wax Ring: Seals the connection between the toilet and the floor to prevent leaks.

A skilled plumber can complete a rebuild in a short time and restore your toilet to near-new condition. If your toilet bowl and tank are in good shape, this option is a practical and affordable fix for many common issues.

Important Considerations for a Replacement

If you choose a new toilet installation, you’ll first need to choose a model that fits your needs and style. There are a lot of options available, ranging from basic models to luxury toilets with advanced features like bidet attachments and heated seats. Professional plumbers will make sure the installation is done correctly so you can avoid leaks and property damage. If you’ve decided on a replacement, here are a few considerations:

• Size and Fit: Measure the space between the wall and the floor drain for compatibility.
• Water Efficiency: Look for models with the WaterSense label to reduce water usage.
• Style and Features: Choose between one-piece and two-piece designs, as well as any additional features you might want.
• Installation Costs: Factor in the cost of professional installation for accurate budgeting.

Do You Need Professional Services?

While DIY repairs can sometimes handle minor issues, serious problems require the help of a professional plumber. Attempting complicated repairs without the right tools and knowledge can lead to more damage and higher repair costs. For a reliable toilet repair, an urgent clogged toilet fix, or a professional installation, the team at Mr. Rooter Plumbing has the skills and experience to get the job done right. Contact us to schedule your appointment.